Pages

Wednesday, 25 June 2014

A very short history of cooking

We recently attempted to recreate a family holiday by the sea, when we first sat on the beach with our children, buckets, spades and a picnic, we did not imagine that twenty years later we would be in the same place sharing beer bought by our eldest son.  This time around we were in a house which was I guess was built just before or after the First World War.  Today the décor seems to been selected to provide a brief sojourn in the lifestyle pages of the Sunday Supplements, but it started life as workman's cottage.  The place was a mini history of cooking, having a range (and a desire on the part of the owners that no one tries to use it), an electric stove (installed with the expectation that no one was going to use it) and a microwave oven.

The size of the rooms was indicative of the way the house was lived in, what was originally the kitchen was the largest communal room, much larger than what is now the living room or parlour as it may have been called.  The old ladies in our family have explained to me that the parlour was rarely used except when the vicar called because family life happened in the kitchen, today, in most homes the living room is just that, the place were you live (or watch TV as it is sometimes known).  Upstairs, only the main bedroom had a small fireplace, the boys bedroom and the girls bedroom were unheated.  I have heard stories about children been sown into their clothes at the start of winter and not been released until spring, this seems like an exaggeration, but maybe there's some basis for it.  The folk memories of our family are that bedroom fires were only lit when mum was nursing new born children or someone was sick.  Thus in many homes the range was the main source of warmth and food.

I have heard a lot about ranges, as girls, the old ladies got the job of cleaning them and as result installed gas and electric stoves in their own homes as soon as the availability of gas, electricity and money allowed.  We have some old school textbooks and manuals of domestic economy which detail the cleaning and operation, which can be summarised as shovelling an rubbing.  Its not hard to see why there are so few surviving examples.  I took the opportunity to poke around this one, the sketch below shows the main components.


The range would be lit most days, even in summer, to provide hot water for tea and washing clothes and bodies.  I'm guessing that the upper grate provided a small fire which provided just enough heat to allow the hot plate to boil a kettle or fry something.  To keep the kitchen warm and make the oven work the lower grate would be used.  The oven is about the same size as that of a modern cooker, my family history suggests that it would be more used to baking bread and pies, than large joints of meat.  By all accounts, it took some skill to cook with a range, not least because of the difficulty of controlling the heat from a coal fire.  Where possible, as much baking was done on a given day of the week where the natural cooling of the oven was the main means of control.  Meat pies and similar items which required long cooking went in first, then as the oven cooled, loaves of bread and finally, small cakes or fancies.

An important job for the range was drying clothing.  There was a horror of damp clothing which was seen as a source of sickness.  I have memories of my mother putting library books in the oven to ward of TB, whilst that seems like strange behaviour, it stemmed from a fear of disease in a time before antibiotics and when doctors charged by the visit.



As with many domestic items made of cast iron, this one has randomly chosen designs, the centrepiece of which is a royal coat of arms.  It not obvious if this is a sign of endorsement, an appeal for loyalty to the crown or just that the maker had the design and felt like using it.

The electric cooker is not that interesting other than where it differs from the range.  Apart from being easy to clean, the first thing about it is that it give instant heat at the turn of a knob thus you don't need to plan the day's eating although if you feel the need, there is a timer.  It has a grill which extends the range of cooking options.  This is more a condemnation of my own cooker, its a lousy space heater.  During the winter, I made bread in the expectation of a warm kitchen not only this, the room was not warm enough for the dough to rise, the result being a cold kitchen and flat bread.

I have limited experience with microwaves, but it seems they to make some contribution to a sustainable energy economy.  It seems that our gas stove consumes between 1 and 5 kw which combined with hot water heating gives an average base load consumption of 10 - 15 kw/day, for not a lot.  Whilst there is no substitute for grasping a frying pan in one hand and a fish slice in the other and cooking over an open flame, a lot of can be done with a microwave.  I've yet to do the sums, but, maybe, it takes 2 kwh to cook an evening meal, could this fall to less than 0.5 kwh if things like carrots can be cooked in 10 minutes in a 600 watt microwave?  And to extend this concept a little further, if a home is equipped with some form of energy storage, much of the cooking could be done using off-peak electricity or from sustainable sources such as wind or solar.

The old ladies would be horrified and my wife is worried, but I am thinking that a range might be just the thing to make our own Edwardian semi as warm and affordable place to live.

Friday, 13 June 2014

Cowboys and Wind

Opposition to wind farms has joined employment, education, taxes in the collection of issues known as politics.  Whilst I offer no opinion on politicians, I feel comfortable in a system which can accommodate this debate and a willingness to tolerate the outcome of elections (albeit grudgingly).  Oddly, for an enthusiast of sustainable energy, I think I see where the opposition to wind farms is coming from, together with similar technologies they are seen as driving up energy costs with no short term benefits for the consumer.  Added to this is the perception that the renewables sector is becoming part of the financial services industry where investments are fuelled by guaranteed energy prices.  Rooftop PV has been sold as an "investment" with gave rates of return greater than that available for standard saving products.

I would like to see a more integrated approach to renewable energy, whilst the unit cost of energy is the headline grabber, it is the total amount spent on energy which is the bottom line for most people.  Promoting energy management and conservation technologies and targeting them in such a way that some people get cost reductions would go a long way to changing the perception of  the sustainable technologies.  This is not a trivial undertaking, but neither was the development of nuclear energy.  At the household level, a few well sited LED lights have cut our electricity cost and I'm hoping that zoning the heating system next year will do the same for the gas bill.  There are ideas out there for politicians to grasp and some of them might even generate jobs and wealth.



A factor in the opposition to wind farms it that the turbines are seen as industrial machines in a pastoral setting, The railways faced similar opposition during the 19th century as the benefits of things like nationwide newspaper and postal distribution became established, they became accepted.  In the 19th century wind power was a mainstream technology with milling and seafaring being more or less respected trades.

Books pile up in our house and there is only so much space available for shelves.  For a book to be saved from the charity shop it either has to have the sort sentimental value that comes from having being a travelling companion (regardless of the fact it was never read) or that it has earned it's place by having been read more than once. One such book is a history of Texas.  About half way through, the author makes an observation that it was only when wind powered water pumps provided drinking water for cattle on the high plains that ranching expanded.  The Aermotor wind pump is as iconic as the nodding donkeys of the oilfields.  Until well into the twentieth century, wind power was a mainstream technology.  Within walking distance of my home there are the surviving structures of three windmills and street names and pub signs hint at the existence of others.  The Dutch have long used wind pumps to drain the low lying parts of their country, a technology they bought to the fenlands of East Anglia.  Today, wind energy is a growing industry in Texas, I recently read that the state produced about 10% of its electricity from wind (figure not checked).


A large, three masted sailing ship like those engaged in the tea trade between Asia and Europe might have been developing the equivalent of 2,000 and 5,000 horsepower when making 14 knots under full sail.  This level of power is comparable to steam and diesel, however, its availability is seasonal and a high level of skill was needed to coordinate agricultural production, maritime transport and marketing.



Saturday, 7 June 2014

Gathering winter fuel (in August)

Last week's blog considered at the how an Edwardian household might have considered energy management, although they would not have used those words, to them it was just housekeeping.  As the twentieth century progressed, housekeeping, for many became less arduous as electric lamps replaced gas mantles and vacuum cleaners sucked filth from carpets which had previously had to be beaten out using things that looked an wickerwork oar.  In the 1970s natural gas displaced coal and probably reduced the frequency of use of vacuum cleaners as gas is a much cleaner fuel than coal.  In our family, the women celebrated the arrival of electricity and none shed a tear for the passing of coal.  Whilst these advances improved many lives, it seems churlish to suggest that the downside was a break with the seasons, today, the seasons are just marked by a bigger gas bill in January.


This picture shows the extensive research that goes into this blog, these bits of insulation blew into my garden during the winter storms.


Managing seasonality is one of the big challenges of a sustainable energy economy.  In my mind, the solution is based on insulation which reduces the demand for energy.  However, this is not a quick fix.  A lot of the UK housing stock was built before 1910 and was drafty by design and what came later until the advent of building regulations that required a high standard of insulation, is not much better.  My perception as the owner of an Edwardian semi is that there are somethings that can be done quickly at an affordable cost such as loft insulation, draft excluders and curtains and maybe, a limited amount of cavity wall insulation.  Anything which would make a significant difference would either change the character of our home, cost more than it would save or both.  A few houses in our area which were built in the 1960s and which were generally regarded as not very nice have been substantially rebuilt to become very attractive buildings, but there are not many of them.   This suggests that the nation's overall domestic energy efficiency will only improve slowly as new homes are built with good insulation, but the older homes, like mine will be an energy embarrassment until it falls down and gets replaced with something different, as I'm fond of my home, I'm attempting to ensure that this is a long time in the future.  A well insulated home which can take advantages of technologies such as air source heat pumps, which my very limited research suggests have a capacity or around 3 - 7 kw.  These devices are not an option for properties which require 20 - 30 kw just to be less cold.  In our case, the solution to rising energy bills and a desire to minimize CO2 emissions is to have a "zoned" system in which only occupied rooms are heated.

The 19th Century was a time when coal was king, if you wander round the older parts of most English towns, you can estimate the number of rooms in a house by counting the number of chimney pots.  The streets in places like Greenwich are punctuated with the covers of coal chutes many of which have intricate patterns rendered in cast iron.  In the same way that North Sea gas displaced coal, coal had started to displace wood two centuries earlier.  Using wood as a fuel requires an understanding of the seasons.  For wood to be a useful fuel it must be dry otherwise much of the heat generated by combustion is absorbed by converting water into steam.  This it was necessary to gather wood during the summer, possibly split the logs and leave it to dry ready for the winter fires.  Sometime back there was a lively debate in the Norwegian press as to the best way to dry logs, was it better to split them and place the split side upwards or place the bark on top.



In recent years, log stores have been appearing in the front porches of many English homes, in part this is due to the appeal of a wood fire.  It's amusing to watch young men in particular light or attempt to light a fire as all sorts of primal instincts and behaviour come to the surface and if girls are present the process becomes a competitive sport.  The main driving force is probably rising fuel prices and as a result wood has become noticeably scarce.  As a regular dog walker, I used to pick up logs on the morning trip to the woods, but since the cold winter of 2010/11, the portable results of any form of woodland maintenance have gone within hours.  Deforestation was a spur to the development of the coal industry in the 18th Century.  Wood is an attractive option, provided only a small number of people use it but it is not substitute for natural gas in urban locations.  Even so, its not unknown for two middle aged dog walkers to glare at each other over a skip containing decking offcuts.  The future is insulation.


Thursday, 29 May 2014

Energy Management - An Edwardian View

Technology often implies a system with sensors feeding some form of computer running highly developed software tuned to make make the best possible decision which is then relayed to a smartphone.  These things did not exist in 1901 when my house was built and I'm now in the process of renovating, in practice this means peeling back a century of things that seemed a good idea at the time.  Electric lights which  were installed around 1925 were an improvement on the gas lamps they replaced but the benefits of some of the plumbing from the 1970's and 1980s is not obvious.



It seems that there have been two distinct phases of energy management, the first from the time the house was built up to 1970 and from then to 2005.  Around 1970, natural gas, also known as North Sea Gas became available in the UK, as a domestic fuel it was both cheaper and less labour intensive than coal which it rapidly displaced.  Whilst coal was not cheap, consumption was in part limited by the availability of labour to burn it.  In much the same way as the speed of early coal-fired steam ships was determined by the rate at which stokers could shovel coal, the amount of coal a house could burn was limited by the labour available to carry  the stuff to the fireplace and dispose of ash the following day.  Our house had six open fires, a coal -fired range for cooking and hot water and a copper for the weekly wash bringing the number of places where coal could be burnt to a total of eight.  Within a relatively short period coal was displaced by gas central heating which warmed the whole house, the only control being an on/off switch,  those  people who found the operation of switch too demanding, delegated this task to an electrically driven timer.  The standard of insulation of houses built before 1970 (and maybe for the next two decades) was not high and coal fires needed a good supply of air to burn properly, so Victorian houses were drafty by design.  The installers of gas fired central heating systems handled this by simply putting in big boilers, often in the range 20 to 40 kw.



I've used the language of the 21st century to describe a household of 1901.  The first of these is "zoning", in modern day terms, this means controlling the heating in two or more parts of the house, often "upstairs" and "downstairs".  For the Edwardians, this meant only lighting a fire in a room which was in use, so in the case of our house, there would have always been a fire during the day in the kitchen range and a fire in the living room during the evening, maybe one in the dining room if friends were coming round for supper and you would probably have had to have man flu or some other ailment to get a warm bedroom.

For lack of a better description, the next difference was "integrated energy use".  When the house was built, cooking was done on a  coal- fired range, whilst these things were no great joy to clean, they were alight for from dawn to dusk which meant there was always one room which was warm.  An industrious cook could use the range to maintain a supply of meals, bread, cakes, tea and coffee.  Managing a range required some skill, a fast fire which would be ideal for frying eggs might make the oven too hot for bread which should be baked in a cooling oven.  Also, when money was in short supply, the fuel might be nutty slack or green wood which required some patience and not a little skill to produce a loaf of bread.  It was the warmth of a kitchen which drew people in from the rest the house.

The third concept was "waste heat recovery", this is a feature of modern boilers which attempt to recover the latent heat from the water vapour which results from burning methane in air.  This can be offset by kitchen extractor fans which take the nice warm air from the kitchen and use it to heat the garden.  The Victorians had some ingenious devices for recovering heat, one which to the best of my knowledge had no domestic application, consisted or a chain rotating at the base of a factory chimney.  The top of the chain was heated by the flu gases from the firebox of the boiler, the bottom of the chain was in the boiler's feed water.  This shows some enthusiasm for energy management.  Within a home, waste heat recovery could be a back boiler on the range or simply a heating coil placed in the flu as part of a simple "gravity feed" hot water system.

What is now part of the modern day kitchen was once a coal store filled from outside the house via shute sealed off with a manhole cover.  The capacity of the coal store was, maybe, two tons which was enough to keep the house functioning for several weeks. This "energy storage" did two things.  At the national level, it evened out the demand for coal, whilst the demand for coal peaked in winter, the capacity of mines and the transport system were probably close to the "average" for the year.  In contrast, whilst the modern gas distribution does have some storage capacity, like the old "gasometers" which used to rise and fall and the more modern method of pumping gas into depleted gas fields, the system is sized to cope with "peak" demand.



Having energy storage at the household level also ensured that there was an effective local energy market, most towns had at least two coal merchants and prices would be lower in summer than winter.  Whilst the modern day gas consumer can "swap" supplier which does provide a measure of competition, this is far removed from an exchange between the coalman and some hard nosed housewife.

Since 2005, energy prices have risen sharply.  There is no economic incentive to revert to coal as a domestic fuel because in terms of body warmth, gas and coal seem to cost about the same and the "clean air acts" control the use of solid.  These bits of legislation were created to bring to an end the plots of "who dunnits" in which heroes and villains could conceal their activities in thick London fog as did Raffles  in the "Ides of March".  However, history might offer some guidance for the future, even if the mobile phone has made it harder for writers of crime fiction.




Friday, 23 May 2014

A ventimeter, a kite and a bicycle

For some time I have been studying wind speed distributions from a variety of sources including airports, offshore buoys, weather balloons and backyards and whilst this has been instructive, it has told me little about the wind where I live. Weather reports from an airfield on open ground 10 km to the west, often don't describe what I see from my house on the west side of an urban valley.  About a year back, a personal weather station appeared on pole a few streets away and since then I have changed my dog walking route to so I can observe the anemometer and wind vane, hopefully without invading anyone's privacy.  Unlike many PWS, this one is clear of roof and tree tops.  It clearly responds long period gusts and the frequent changes of direction which seem to be a feature of urban wind, often the anemometer is gently turning with the vane fluttering in the direction of the prevailing all of which suggests a wind speed of less than 5 m/s.


 


I have attempted to gain some understanding of wind in the area I live in by cycling around with a hand held ventimeter type wind speed measuring device, these efforts have been described in a couple of previous posts (fortunately, my family only rarely read this blog).  This too was quite useful, but my arms only extend to 2 metres which is close to the ground for serious wind speed measurement.  Recently, I have started messing with a small kite, not only is this instructive and three dimensional, it is also fun.  The ventimeter attracted little attention, except from an alsatian dog called Trooper, but most people smile at the kite, especially old ladies.  Maybe there is some point to be made about making environmental science accessible, but life is too short.

The kite is difficult to fly in even light turbulence, sometimes on a gusty day, a random swirl of wind will take it into relatively smooth air where it fill fly contentedly as long at the air keeps moving, once the gust subsides, it returns to Earth..  Having spent a lot of my life crunching numbers, it has been a surprise, how much can be learnt without a single keystroke.  Whilst its short on numbers, the kite provides an indication of the change of turbulence with height.  In the sketch below, the layers and circles are very roughly at 10, 20 and 30m, the arrows are relatively smooth air and the circles represent turbulence.


Wind blowing off the sea is usually smooth, however, wind coming from the land can become turbulent if it passes over trees and buildings.  On a coastal plane, hedges can create local turbulence below relatively smooth air.  In urban areas, the wind is almost always turbulent, at least up to treetop height.  I would not recommend flying a kite in an urban area to investigate.  I have always been curious about the performance of three medium sized wind turbines in the vicinity of Dagenham which I have seen turning smoothly.  On ridges above the surrounding land, gusting is less than on the approaching slopes.  If the wind is flowing up the slope it can be relatively smooth, but if the slope is in the wind shadow of a ridge, it can be almost calm with only long period gusts.

These comments have the caveat that they are drawn from a small sample collected across a relatively small area using a kite.





Friday, 16 May 2014

Diffuse Irradiance (Part 3)


A project which has been going on for an embarrassingly long time requires the ability to take a weather forecast and turn it into a forecast of possible wind and solar energy.  The concept is that some software downloads a weather forecast (in this case a TAF) and estimates the amount of solar energy that a PV Panel might produce.  If overcast conditions are likely to prevail for the next 24 hours, it charges it's batteries using off-peak electricity.  This requires a simple cloud sky model which in turn requires a simple clear sky model.  The clear sky model base based on Sun-Earth geometry and gives an estimate of the solar irradiance from a sky with no clouds, the cloud sky model then reduces the clear sky irradiance according to the nature of the cloud cover.  At this stage, work on the cloud sky model  consists of grinding out the correlations.

After some experimenting, it was decided to use a correlation found in "Applied Solar Energy" by A.P. and M.P. Meinel which was published by Addison Wesley in 1976.  Despite being based on observations made in the Mojave Desert in the late 60s this formula provides reasonable estimates of Direct Normal Irradiance (DNI)  for several climate types.  It is a simple model, requiring only input being Air Mass.  What I could not find was an equivalent for formula for clear sky Direct Horizontal Irradiance (DHI).  I had gained a little experience of making solar irradiance measurements whilst cloud watching in the back yard.  This formed the basis for a crude prototype shaded radiometer, but having collected data for just over a year, it is still in its crude form, this is partly due to laziness, but mainly the risk of introducing inconsistencies into the results.

Observations are made on clear days, there is more data for moorings than afternoons.  Even though an English day might start with a clear sky, clouds start to form mid-morning.  I still need to collect some more readings when the air mass is in the range 1.5 to 3.0.  The graph below shows the results to date of spending several sunny mornings in the park or on the beach:


An important part of the observing routine is making notes on the state of the sky.  Diffuse irradiance increases significantly when conditions are hazy or cumulus cloud is forming/dispersing, observations made under these conditions were discarded from the correlation, they are the green series on the graph.  Excel's Solver was used to produce this correlation:


This formula should be treated with caution, if only because it has not been reviewed by anyone other than the author.  Also, the calibration of the radiometer needs to be reviewed.  In addition, the Sun-Earth geometry code has been revised an recently ported to Python and is still being tested.  Thus some form of revision is likely.

This the shaded radiometer in use:



I would have liked to made some observations whilst the dust from the Saharan Desert was airborne over the UK around April-03, at a guess this would have resulted in above average levels of diffuse irradiance.



Friday, 9 May 2014

Conservation - It helps if you get payback!

Two questions which arise about a sustainable energy economy are "why" and "how".  Most people accept the desirability of minimizing our dependence on fossil/nuclear sources, but it's perceived as a long term aspiration with few, if any, short term benefits.  Politicians like to talk about "investment" in energy saving technology, effectively moving the problem into the future, they are less comfortable with promoting energy saving behaviour.  Back in the winter, some journalists attempted to get a minister to say the people should wear jumpers if they were cold, this is maybe appropriate advice, but a statement open to misrepresentation.  My guess is that most people having problems with rising energy bills were already wearing at least two pullovers.  One thing which does encourage conservation is things which payback in a reasonable time, i.e. in months, not decades.

Over the past year, I've spent about £60 on LED lights, the first two did not win hearts and minds and they have been relegated to my workspace, but two 3 watt 360 degree bulbs have replaced some passage lights which are most frequently turned on, so 12 watts of LED's have replaced 80 watts of CFL's.  This drop in consumption has, in part, caused my electricity provider to repatriate £60 to our bank account.  I now have an incentive to go and install some more LEDs.  The current crop of LEDs are not a good fit for every place we've got a CFL, but I'm certain I can work a few into the sitting room.


No one noticed the change from a 20 watt CFL to a 3 watt LED in this hall light.

I've had this conversation a couple of times and read accounts of similar ones in the papers.  When people install rooftop PV, almost the first thing they do is attempt to balance generation and consumption.  If they were taking 3,500 kwh from the grid each year, they try and get this down to the amount generated by the panels, say, 2,500 kwh.  A 1,000 kwh/year saving comes quite easily although it may cause tensions within the family if someone becomes too obsessive.  Do you have to spend more than £5,000 before you go and find out how much energy your daughter's hair straighteners use.  The domestic upset caused a daughter with manky hair, is in my opinion, too high a price, even to save the planet.  A better target is the laundry, especially, if there is a tumble dryer involved.   If your lifestyle permits it and you have the space, invest in a washing line or whirligig.  I suggest that a washing line is a solar thermal device and eligible for the government's Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI).  Some not too sophisticated sums suggest that that hanging out the washing, can save several hundred kwh/year relative to a tumble dryer.  I live in fear of my ragged underpants becoming a permanent feature of Google Earth but  it is a small price to pay for saving the planet.


The picture shows a solar thermal device in action.  The drying frame cost about £20 and dries washing with a combination of wind and solar energy, maybe it generates a few hundred kwh/year, contrast this with a rooftop solar water heater which in England's climate also generates the same amount.

And my point is.  I'm not going to comment on the merit of schemes like Feed-in Tariffs, RHI and subsidies for electric vehicles, mainly because I have not studied them in sufficient depth to have an informed opinion other than to say that they create an impression that sustainability can only be achieved through major "investment".  These schemes have wider implications than sustainability, they also impact job creation, stimulate new industries.  New, low cost technologies and small behaviour changes also have a roll to play.  This poses the question, if installing rooftop PV causes a drop in consumption,  how can you achieve the same saving without the up front payment.  Will the prime minister's underwear ever be found on Google Earth?